So I was thinking about Bear Creek. Since I take the 11:57 to Great Umbrage whenever I think of EPS-based price targets for miners, especially in a buyout situation, I decided to play with finding a ciggypack DCF NAV value.
So first, I removed the assumed $25M/yr interest (cos I subtract capex off the top afterwards - see below). Then I took that modified net income estimate and stuffed it through excel with a 23-yr mine life and 8% discount rate (you could even use 10% or 12%, since the natives are restless and El Presidente's a screaming Bolivarian communist).
Sum over 23 years, and then subtract $650M off the top for the capex.
This is what I get for DCF NAVs, and what it would mean per ounce silver in the ground:
$1.7 billion at $25 Ag, or $5.24/oz (no inferred),
$2.1 billion at $30 Ag, or $6.44/oz,
$2.5 billion at $35 Ag, or $7.63/oz, and
$2.9 billion at $40 Ag, or $8.83/oz.
What's the typical price for a silver buyout nowadays, per ounce in the ground? Obviously nobody pays $2B for Corani if that's their projected NAV. At the same time, if the cash costs post credits are near-zero cos of the lead and zinc, I could almost see an exec being able to justify paying $5/oz for a project. Not that I know anything about the mining world. But $5/oz seems something you could get people to agree with.
Anyway, if the buyout comes at 50% of NAV, that's $9.40, $11.55, $13.69 or $15.83 per share. Since the latter target is only for $40 Ag, I can see why Sprott would (or should) piddle his panties over BCM.
I'm actually going to be interested in reading the feasibility study, if it's still coming in 3q11.
UPDATE 1: whoops, just checked the MD&A and now they're saying it'll be 4Q11. Well, no wonder the buying pressure dried up.
UPDATE 2: whoops, the MD&A does the math for me, dumbass. Here's what it says on p.5:
If August 12, 2011 spot metal prices ($38.29 silver, $1.08 lead and $0.98 zinc) were used in the economic model contained in the PFS, without adjusting any of the other inputs, the after-tax net present value of the project would be $2.1 billion at a 5% discount rate. The project would also have an internal rate of return of 87%. Readers are cautioned that this information is supplementary only and although the PFS does contain some sensitivity analysis, this information should not be considered in isolation or as a substitute for the net present values and internal rates of return contained in the PFS, which were prepared in accordance with prescribed and standardized methods.
I haven't seen the old PFS, but from the numbers given on MD&A p.5 it looks like the Corani project's design front-loads high-grade ore. Which, I guess it should. That means my DCF NAV above is wrong (because I was assuming constant grade): but that's only because it's based on Otto's EPS calc, which is also wrong (because he was assuming constant grade and he's a newsletter writer so he should really know better).
i like a laugh
ReplyDeleteIt would be wonderful for this to happen at the multiples you spell out...However, Would you buy BCM at that price?
ReplyDeleteDoesnt seem to be much M&A in the PM sector anyway so pretty much a moot point.
I have no idea.. like I said, I'm sure a buyout happens at a specific fraction of NAV, since I the buyer have to be able to justify it to my board. But I don't know what fraction of NAV buyouts happen at nowadays. What was the NAV of Altar when PGM got bought out?
ReplyDeleteAnyway, count $1/share for cash, and some small amount of money for Santa Ana since BCM probably will get at least some small amount of compensation, and the whole point of this was me trying to justify buying BCM at $3.80.
Seems like a good deal to me. At least it's not potentially infinite downside.
M&A will pick up, so the talking heads insist. You'd think with gold at all-time highs, silver approaching that level again, that once maybe $HUI pops over 610 the M&A activity will really start to fly.
Always when everything's the most expensive....
Altar is mainly a copper play so different forces/multiples at work.
ReplyDeleteNot sure what a good multiple is for a silver play. Have you seen any get bought out?